The SRA had a small division named Trackfast, responsible for parcels and small freight to about 300 country towns. In 1989, Gary Camp was appointed to the position of General Manager, and inherited a management team. Camp also inherited an incredibly fragmented organisation, that had many independently operating sections.
Camp understood that the organisation had to undergo major changes. The organisation had previously rendered services, but had not recorded a profit, and had no plans to do so. In the years of 1986-87, the Trackfast recorded losses of $42.4 million dollars. By 1989, it had projected losses of $32.1 million. Camp had been appointed turn Trackfast into a profit oriented organisation.
Camp came up with a plan to make Trackfast profitable. To cut a long story short, Camp had not acted dishonestly by the end of the whole thing. The person who was at fault was Tony Wilson, who had acted corruptly.
Wilson had offered contracts to a company called Extran. The contracts were worth in excess of $3.6 million. Extran overcharged Trackfast by over $170 000, with the approval of Tony Wilson. It was found that Gary Camp had unknowingly assisted Tony Wilson, as Wilson had misled Camp. Wilson was the only person found to have acted corruptly.
It should be noted, however, that Camp managed to change losses $42 million to a projected profit of $3.4 million.
From the Sydney Morning Herald, on the 29th of September, 1992:
Corruption in State Rail's freight business, Trackfast, had occurred after the NSW Government had put too much pressure on management to return a profit, the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) found yesterday.
The ICAC assistant commissioner, Mr Ronald Sackville, QC, also severely criticised Trackfast for management failures in his report on corruption in the organisation.
Mr Sackville found that the former fleet manager of Trackfast, Mr Tony Wilson, had acted corruptly and should be sacked for secretly assisting a tenderer to obtain valuable contracts from State Rail.
He also found that the former Trackfast general manager, Mr Gary Camp, was not corrupt but should be sacked for unwittingly helping Mr Wilson.
State Rail dismissed both employees last January and cancelled its contract with Extran, the company Mr Wilson had favoured to win business worth $3.6 million.
Mr Sackville said that it was important for State Rail and other public organisations not to dismiss this incident in Trackfast's history as simply a case of wrongdoing, compounded by the ineptitude by the general manager.
"These elements comprise only part of the story," he said.
Mr Sackville said that corruption did not occur in a vacuum and indicated that a decision to restructure Trackfast in 1989 to achieve full cost recovery in two years was relevant to his inquiry.
The financial performance of Trackfast had improved from a disastrous base, although profitability was never achieved, he said.
"What is striking, however, is how little appears to have been done specifically to train and support those charged with responsibility for fundamentally restructuring Trackfast," he said.
"... The staff considered themselves to be under very considerable pressure to achieve swift results in an uncertain environment, on the pain of closure of the enterprise should the endeavour fail."
According to Mr Sackville's report, Mr Wilson provided improper support to Mr Stuart Taylor and Mr Malcolm Chapman, the principals of Extran, in the drafting of tenders for two significant contracts - the metropolitan door-to-door contract and delivery of freight to the NSW South Coast.
A spokesman for the Minister for Transport, Mr Baird, said yesterday that the minister accepted Mr Sackville's opinion that tough goals had been set for Trackfast in an attempt to cut public costs.
But he defended the performance of Trackfast, saying that it had gone from a loss of $40 million a year to a projected profit of $3.4 million this year.
"We are not making an apology for setting tough standards," the spokesman said. "But we are not excusing misconduct either."
The spokesman said that, in hindsight, Mr Baird could see that tighter controls could have been put in place at Trackfast - and State Rail had now addressed these problems.
The chief executive of State Rail, Mr Ross Sayers, defended the record of State Rail, saying that tough goals had been set across the organisation.
"The tough standards were no excuse for the conduct of certain employees which has been detailed by Mr Sackville in his report," he said.
Mr Sackville has also conducted hearings into State Rail's hire of earthmoving equipment in the north of the State and is due to issue a report later this year.
No comments:
Post a Comment