Tuesday, May 20, 2008

RailCorp Structural Danger - Interview with an architect

I interviewed my father, Karl Prince (architect), briefly about railway structures.


So what was wrong with that car park? Or, what is wrong with it.

Well, I don’t really know what was wrong with it. They determined that if a train derailed underneath it, the whole thing would fall down, pretty much. But I think they might’ve corrected that now, placed a whole lot of concrete barriers and all that sort of stuff up to protect the structure above.

Is there anywhere else that you think could be structurally faulty? You mentioned Kogarah..

Kogarah has a similar problem, but it’s protected by platforms. You never know.

What about Hurstville with the Super Centre above it?

That’s the same as Kogarah. Kogarah and Hurstville are the same.

How dangerous is that? If a train was to derail before they had done all those upgrades…

Well, they didn’t really upgrade Kogarah. Although they are starting to do some areas of Hurstville, I think. There’s some isolated structures outside, beyond the platform.

With the Goulbourn St Carpark, before they did the upgrades on it, if a train had derailed under there, what impact would that have on the building?

I don’t know how tall it was, I think it was a five or six storey carpark. Because of the type of structure it was, which was mainly precast concrete, the whole thing would’ve come down. It’s only a carpark.

Safety inspections – is that something they’d have to do every year? Whose responsibility is that?

The people that build over the top of railway infrastructure usually have air rights leases. I don’t know whose responsibility it is, whether it’s the responsibility of the people who own the air rights, over the top of the railways, or whether it’s the railways themselves. It’s very complicated.

What about the Cahill Expressway above Circular Quay?

That had a lot of concern around it because of structural defects. Concrete cancer, they called it. The Cahill Expressway was built under Bradfield, that’s why they called it the Bradfield Highway, and he designed the underground – what do you call it – the city loop, like Town Hall, Museum, and all those stations around there. From Wynyard to Museum and Central, he designed that railway city loop, and that was part of his thing. But that got under scrutiny because of concrete cancer, exfoliation or erosion of protective materials, and things like that one the steelwork.

How old are those structures?

I’m not sure exactly. The Goulbourn Street Parking Station was part of those developments too. It goes back a long time. I mean, Bradfield was responsible for the Harbour Bridge, as well. Early 1900’s. That was a part of his whole job. But! It’s a long time, and the maintenance to keep it all going is hard to maintain. And what with the technology these days, what we know these days, compared to what we knew back then – you can imagine the difference. We didn’t have TV!

They did build it, to an extent, with expansion in mind, but did they build it thinking it would last another hundred years?

I think they built it thinking that it would last forever. But I don’t think, knowing what we know now, they had the resources and information to make it last forever. You could do something now to make it last forever, what with all of the advancements we’ve had in technology. But back then, they were pioneers.

No comments: