Sunday, May 18, 2008

ICAC vs. Railcorp Maintenance Engineer, aka How to subvert your employer and satisfy your greed.

I'll be focusing on the ICAC investigation into Railcorp Maintenance Engineer Said Marcos, who managed to illegally pocket upwards of $700,000 over a period of six years by giving out air-conditioning contracts to his friends.

ICAC have plenty of documentation relating to the investigation available on their website (links listed at the end of this post) but in the interest brevity here's a summary of what went on and who was involved:

THE ACCUSED
Said Marcos - Railcorp Maintenance Engineer. Owner of two businesses, "Isis" and "S&B"
Tony Mourched - Owner of "NBR"
Sami Mikhail - Owner of two businesses; "Sami Industrial & Domestic Cleaners" and "Atsan"

THE TIMELINE
Illegal conduct: 1999 - 2005
ICAC Investigation: Public inquiry began December 4th, 2006
Story broke: June 2007

THE INQUIRY FINDINGS
Over a period of six years Mr. Marcos assigned contracts to the companies owned by Mr. Mourched and Mr. Mikhail. Mourched's company NBR received approximately $4 million for the work done over that six year period. In return, Mr. Mourched and Mr. Mikhail assigned lucrative subcontract work to the companies owned by Mr. Marcos. In addition to this, Mr. Marcos also received a share of the profits earned by Mr. Mourched and Mr. Mikhail's company for the work they completed. Mr. Marcos made a total of $710,000 from the deals. None of this was done with Railcorp's knowledge.

THE RESULTS
ICAC recommended that charges be laid against Mr. Marcos and also submitted a list of 27 anti-corruption recommendations to Railcorp for their consideration. Since then, Railcorp have reportedly taken disciplinary action against Mr. Marcos, suspending him without pay. No mention of actual legal prosecution has been made, reinforcing the idea that the ICAC is something of a toothless tiger. Clichéd expressions involving anatomically impaired wildlife aside,  it's unfortunate that the ICAC has no real power to prosecute those they investigate, which makes it easy to draw comparisons between them and the frequent lack of punishment to those who undermine Freedom of Information laws (you know, the government.)

THE MEDIA COVERAGE
Unlike the structural danger with Hurstville station, this issue isn't over particularly great concern to public safety, and so it garnered virtually nothing in the way of widespread media coverage. An extensive Factiva search of all articles featuring the phrases "Railcorp and air conditioning" or "Railcorp and Said Marcos" yielded only half a dozen results, suggesting that there has been very little in the way of thorough investigative journalism linked to this story.

FEATURED STORIES
Articles relating to the issue that have been published in The Sydney Morning Herald and The Daily Telegraph are currently inaccessible without payment.

WHERE DOES FREEDOM OF INFORMATION COME INTO IT ALL?
As I've already stated, this story hasn't attracted too much in the way of  widespread media coverage so I dare say that frustrations with the Freedom of Information Act weren't a particularly big concern for journalists on this occasion. Most of the relevant information was released via ICAC's website in the form of media releases, official reports, and transcripts. No applications or requests had to be submitted, it was all instantly accessible, which is more or less the epitome of an idealistic freedom of information model. 

But given the ongoing media attention Railcorp are receiving (leaving them with what seems to be a perpetual air of corruption) it's possible that this issue, although relatively small in the grand scheme of things, could later become part of an in-depth analysis of corruption within Railcorps' ranks, should one ever be published. In this instance it's not inconceivable that the journalist or journalists involved with the publication of such a piece might face considerable difficulties with responses to Freedom of Information requests by Railcorp, who may do everything within their power to remain as tight-lipped as possible on matters relating to this and other incidents.


RELATED LINKS

No comments: