Friday, May 30, 2008

RailCorp Structural Danger - Summary

Here is the overall summary of the investigation of RailCorp launched by the Sydney Morning Herald.

• Facts of the case

RailCorp knew from some time around 2003 (possibly earlier) that some of the buildings over the tracks were in disrepair, and could pose a risk to the public in the event of a train derailment. The main buildings of concern were the Hurstville Super Centre, Goulbourn Street Parking Station, and the Cahill Expressway over Circular Quay.

The Sydney Morning Herald, lead mainly by Anne Davies and Michael Moore, began investigating the case in 2004. They made two separate requests in 2004 and 2005 for the information from RailCorp. In late 2004 they obtained a report from RailCorp, which stated that there were faults in some buildings - however in the report, these were only estimations and did not go into specific detail as to what buildings were at risk, and how severe the situation was.

In 2007, Michael Moore campaigned for further details under FOI. After RailCorp refused to give him more information, he took his request to the NSW Ombudsman, who in turn put pressure on RailCorp to release the information. The battle became very much public, with Moore writing several pieces in the Herald about the abuse of FOI by RailCorp. Finally, in March 2007, they recieved enough information from RailCorp to piece together the full picture. More than 60 sites along the CityRail network were in disrepair, some enough to be labelled a serious threat to commuters travelling along the network.

• Who broke the story
Michael Moore and Anne Davies.

• What were the ramifications of the story
RailCorp were discredited by the story, as their refusal to cooperate with the journalists meant that they lost their transparency. Among so many other scandals, the findings of structural faults simply added to the air of secrecy surrounding the organisation.

As a result of the investigation, and the ensuing public panic, RailCorp took steps to ensure the safety of passengers. These included installing extra guardrails along the tracks to prevent derailment, replacement of eroded concrete supports, and steel reinforcement in some buildings. Some buildings were knocked down, however this was unrelated to the Herald investigation.

• Who was involved in the case
RailCorp Chief Executive Vince Graham (moved to Integral Energy)
2007 Minister for Transport John Watkins

• How did the journalist research the information to write the story
A lot of the information obtained by Moore and Davies was from the FOI requests. They also conducted their own research, through photographing the sites along the network and assessing the danger themselves.

• Ethical and legal dilemma’s involved in the investigation
There is the ethical dilemma of creating public panic, however, as none of the buildings were in critical disrepair, this would be unlikely. As RailCorp is meant to be held accountable by the public, there should be no legal issues in trying to obtain information from them and publishing critisms of the CityRail network.

• Use of external bodies i.e regulators in bringing this matter to the attention of the public
NSW Ombudsman. This was more of a last resort. Moore explored the issue in depth again in March 2008, when RailCorp continued to refuse the information.

No comments: